In the ever-evolving landscape of music production, the choice between hardware can significantly influence a producer’s creative process and workflow efficiency. Two standout contenders in this arena are the Ableton Push 3 and the Maschine Plus Standalone. Both units offer a unique set of features tailored to meet the demands of modern beat makers, yet they cater to distinct preferences and production styles. The Ableton Push 3, with its deep integration into the Ableton Live ecosystem and extensive connectivity, promises a seamless bridge between software and hardware. On the other hand, the Maschine Plus Standalone, renowned for its immersive workflow and robust design, offers a comprehensive solution for producers seeking a more autonomous production experience. This comparison aims to dissect the nuances of each, providing clarity to producers weighing their options in a market brimming with potential.
Spec Comparison:
| Feature | Ableton Push 3 | Maschine Plus Standalone |
| Standalone Capability | Standalone instrument | Immersive standalone workflow |
| Pads | 64 sensitive MPE-enabled pads | 16 velocity-sensitive pads |
| Audio Interface | Built-in, with 2 x 6.3mm balanced inputs and outputs, ADAT in/out | Pro-grade, 44.1 kHz / 24-bit with 2 x ¼” TRS line outputs and inputs, ¼” dynamic mic input |
| Connectivity | CV & Gate, USB-A, USB-C, MIDI in/out, dynamic ports for pedal input and CV output, external power | WiFi and Link enabled, MIDI In/Out, Footswitch, 2 x USB ports for MIDI controllers/external HDDs |
| Processor & Storage | Upgradeable processor, battery, hard drive | Quad-core CPU and 4 GB RAM |
| Screen and Interface | Large LCD screen, jog wheel for library search and MIDI editing | Not specified, but Maschine hardware typically includes dual high-resolution screens |
| Included Software and Sounds | Live Intro, 19 Packs with over 40GB of sound content and over 4100 presets | MASCHINE+ Selection with industry-leading instruments, sounds, effects, drum and bass synth plugins |
| Design and Build | Not specified | Robust, anodised aluminium design |
| Size and Weight | 380mm x 318mm x 44.5mm (H), 3.95kg | Not specified, but Maschine hardware is known for its portability and robust build |
| Performance Features | MPE support, integration with Ableton Live, extensive I/O for modular and studio integration | Iconic MASCHINE workflow, effects, and plugins, step sequencer, vintage sampler emulation, standalone or computer integration |
PADS
| Feature | Ableton Push 3 Pads | Maschine Plus Standalone Pads |
| Quantity | 64 pads | 16 pads |
| Sensitivity | MPE-enabled, sensitive to velocity and pressure | Velocity-sensitive, designed for dynamic performance |
| Size | Smaller, to accommodate the higher quantity on the interface | Larger, offering more surface area for each pad |
| Expressiveness | Support for MIDI Polyphonic Expression (MPE) allows for more nuanced performance with each pad detecting subtle variations in touch | Primarily focused on velocity sensitivity, allowing for expressive beat making and performance |
| Layout | Arranged in an 8×8 matrix, optimizing space for complex performances and sequences | Arranged in a 4×4 matrix, offering a straightforward layout for beat making and live performance |
| Integration | Designed for seamless integration with Ableton Live, enabling direct control over software features | Tailored for the MASCHINE ecosystem, with a workflow that complements the software’s drum programming and sampling capabilities |
- Ableton Push 3 Pads: Ideal for users seeking a high degree of control and expressiveness within the Ableton Live ecosystem. The 64 MPE-enabled pads offer a level of sensitivity and responsiveness that caters to intricate performances and detailed sequencing.
- Maschine Plus Standalone Pads: Best suited for users who prioritize the tactile feel and size of the pads for beat making. The 16 large pads provide a comfortable and intuitive layout for dynamic performances and are highly regarded for their feel and responsiveness.
Choosing between these two largely depends on the user’s preference for pad size and layout, as well as how they plan to integrate the controller into their music production and performance workflow.
For beat makers deeply integrated into the Ableton ecosystem, or those seeking extensive studio and modular gear integration, the Push 3 appears to be a comprehensive tool. Its standout features include a vast array of sensitive MPE-enabled pads for expressive performances, a built-in audio interface with extensive connectivity options, and the ability to upgrade hardware components.
Conversely, the Maschine Plus Standalone is an all-in-one beat making powerhouse for producers preferring a standalone workflow or those who value the iconic Maschine workflow and sound. It offers robust performance features, a pro-grade audio interface, and wireless capabilities for updates and collaboration, all within a portable, road-ready design.
Each device caters to different aspects of music production and performance. The user’s preferred workflow, the ecosystem they are invested in (Ableton Live vs. Native Instruments), and the specific features that best suit their creative process should guide them in choosing between each device for different aspects of music production and performance.
